VAT can be one of those bills that feels a long way off, until suddenly it is not.
Money comes through the till every day, but by the time the VAT deadline arrives, some of it may already have been used to pay wages, suppliers, rent, loan repayments or an unexpected repair.
This can be particularly difficult where a busy VAT quarter is followed by a quieter trading period, or where the business has recently spent money on equipment or a refurbishment.
It is not unusual for a restaurant, pub, café or hotel to reach the VAT deadline without enough cash available to pay the bill in full. That does not automatically mean the business is failing, but it does need to be dealt with quickly. Ignoring it will usually make the position more expensive and more difficult to resolve.
First, Check the VAT Bill and Submit the Return
It goes without saying that you should first check the VAT return and make sure the amount due looks reasonable. Once you are happy that it is correct, submit the return on time; even if you cannot pay the bill in full.
Late filing and late payment are treated separately by HMRC, so holding back the return does not buy the business any extra time. It simply risks creating a second compliance problem on top of the unpaid VAT.
You can find more information in HMRC’s guidance on sending a VAT return, including late returns and payments.
What Happens If You Pay VAT Late?
Late-payment interest starts from the first day after the payment deadline and continues until the outstanding VAT has been paid in full.
HMRC’s late-payment interest rate is linked to the Bank of England base rate and as of writing is currently set at the base rate plus four percentage points. As the rate can change, it is worth checking HMRC’s current interest rates for late and early payments.
For most current VAT liabilities, the late-payment penalties broadly work as follows:
- If the VAT is paid in full within the first 15 days, there is no late-payment penalty, although interest will still apply.
- There will also normally be no late-payment penalty if a Time to Pay proposal is made within the first 15 days and that proposal subsequently results in an agreed arrangement.
- If the VAT remains unpaid after day 15, the first penalty is 3% of the amount outstanding at the end of day 15.
- If the VAT remains unpaid after day 30, a further 3% is charged on the amount still outstanding at the end of day 30.
- From day 31, a further penalty accrues daily at an annual rate of 10% on the outstanding balance.
Older VAT liabilities can fall under different penalty rates, so the relevant period should be checked where the business has historic debts.
For example, if a £20,000 VAT liability remained completely unpaid at both day 15 and day 30, the first two penalty elements would total £1,200. That would be in addition to late-payment interest and the daily penalty beginning from day 31.
This is why a part payment can still be worthwhile. Paying down the balance before days 15 and 30 can reduce the amount on which the penalties are calculated, even where the business cannot clear the whole bill.
What Should You Do If You Cannot Pay?
Pay What You Reasonably Can
Don’t leave the whole liability unpaid simply because the business cannot clear it in full.
A part payment reduces the outstanding debt, the interest accruing and potentially the late-payment penalties.
However, this does not mean emptying the bank account without considering wages, essential suppliers and the business’s ability to continue trading. The payment needs to form part of a realistic short-term cash-flow plan.
Contact HMRC as Early as Possible
HMRC may agree a Time to Pay arrangement, allowing the VAT debt to be cleared through monthly instalments rather than one immediate payment.
Some straightforward arrangements can be set up online without having to provide a lengthy supporting pack. Where the debt is larger, the proposed term is longer or the business’s finances are more complicated, HMRC may want more information.
The business may be asked about:
- how much it can pay immediately;
- how much it can afford each month;
- its income and essential spending;
- other HMRC debts or payment arrangements;
- loans and commercial finance commitments;
- available savings, assets or borrowing facilities; and
- how it will pay new tax liabilities while clearing the existing debt.
An existing Time to Pay arrangement or other unpaid HMRC debts can make the process more complicated. HMRC will usually want to consider the wider position rather than looking at the latest VAT bill in isolation.
Before contacting HMRC, work out how much can be paid immediately, what monthly instalment is genuinely affordable and when the next VAT, PAYE and other tax liabilities will fall due.
You can check your options and start the process through HMRC’s guidance on setting up a payment plan when you cannot pay a tax bill on time.
Interest will continue to run on the outstanding balance during a Time to Pay arrangement. However, an agreed arrangement can prevent or reduce late-payment penalties, depending on when the proposal is made.
What Should You Avoid Doing?
The main things to avoid are:
- ignoring the debt and waiting for HMRC to chase it;
- delaying the VAT return because the money is not available;
- agreeing to instalments that the business is unlikely to maintain;
- using all of the cash reserved for the next VAT return to clear the old one without a wider recovery plan;
- continuing with unnecessary spending while asking HMRC for additional time;
- paying dividends, drawings or director’s loan repayments without considering the overdue tax; and
- accepting expensive short-term finance without comparing its full cost.
A payment arrangement only works if the business can meet both the instalments and its new tax liabilities.
If the arrangement is unaffordable and fails after one or two months, HMRC may cancel it and apply penalties as though the arrangement had not been in place. The business may then find itself with the original debt, new VAT liabilities and a failed payment plan.
Should You Use an EPOS or Card-Linked Loan to Pay VAT?
Hospitality businesses are often offered quick funding through their card processor, EPOS provider or till system.
These products can be appealing because the application process is usually straightforward, the provider already has access to the business’s sales history and repayments are collected automatically from future card takings.
The business receives money upfront and repays an agreed total amount through deductions from its card sales. These products are often described as merchant cash advances or card-linked finance.
The British Business Bank’s guide to merchant cash advances explains how this type of funding works and some of the potential risks.
Easy access does not necessarily mean cheap or suitable finance.
The cost may be expressed as a fixed fee rather than a conventional interest rate. In some agreements, repaying the advance more quickly does not reduce the fee. The deduction from daily card receipts can also leave the business with less cash available for wages, suppliers and the next VAT bill.
Before accepting an offer, compare:
- the total amount that will be repaid;
- the proportion of card sales that will be deducted;
- the likely repayment period during both busy and quiet trading;
- whether repaying the finance early reduces the cost;
- the effect of the deductions on the next VAT and PAYE payments;
- any personal guarantee or other security; and
- the cost against HMRC interest and penalties under a realistic repayment timetable.
Tax treatment should also be included in the comparison.
Where commercial funding is used for business purposes, the interest or finance charge will generally attract tax relief, subject to the legal structure of the product and the normal tax rules.
VAT late-payment interest and HMRC penalties, however, are not deductible when calculating taxable profits. The options should therefore be compared on an after-tax basis rather than by looking only at the headline costs.
Even after allowing for tax relief, an expensive card-linked facility may still cost considerably more than dealing with the debt through HMRC. The tax deduction reduces the effective cost; it does not make expensive borrowing cheap.
In some cases, commercial finance may still be appropriate because it allows the business to clear the VAT quickly and avoid further penalties or enforcement action. The comparison needs to be made using the actual figures rather than assuming either option will always be better.
Make Sure HMRC Allocates Your Payment Correctly
Payment allocation is particularly important where the business already has older VAT debts.
For example, a business may owe VAT from an earlier return as well as an amount on its latest return. It might make a payment intending to clear the latest liability before it reaches one of the penalty dates.
If HMRC allocates that payment to the older debt instead, the latest liability may remain outstanding and continue to attract penalties and interest.
Where there are several VAT liabilities:
- make the intended allocation clear when the payment is made;
- use the correct payment reference;
- keep the bank-payment details and evidence;
- check the VAT account afterwards; and
- contact HMRC promptly if the payment has not been applied as intended.
Do not assume that a payment will automatically be allocated to the latest VAT return.
The best allocation will depend on the age of each debt, the penalties already charged and the interest and penalties that could arise next. Clearing the oldest or newest debt is not automatically the right answer in every case.
Is the Business Using the Right VAT Scheme?
Changing VAT schemes will not remove a bill that has already arisen, but it may be worth reviewing whether the business is using the most suitable arrangement for the future.
Depending on its turnover, sales pattern, customer payment terms and level of VAT-bearing costs, the business may be better suited to the Cash Accounting Scheme, Flat Rate Scheme or Annual Accounting Scheme. It may also be worth considering whether monthly or quarterly returns fit its cash-flow cycle better.
These options are not automatically better for hospitality businesses. Cash accounting may provide little benefit where customers pay immediately, the Flat Rate Scheme can cost more rather than less, and annual accounting can still result in a large balancing payment.
Any proposed change should therefore be modelled using the business’s actual figures before it is made.
Why Was the Money Not There?
Sometimes the VAT shortfall is a one-off timing issue.
Perhaps the business has recently completed a refurbishment, replaced essential equipment or reached the VAT deadline immediately after a seasonal slowdown.
If the same problem happens repeatedly, there is usually an underlying issue that needs to be identified.
Common causes include:
- food or drink margins being too low;
- wage costs being too high for the level of sales;
- rent and other fixed overheads being unaffordable;
- too much cash being committed to loans or merchant cash advances;
- capital expenditure being made without allowing for upcoming tax payments;
- excessive drawings, dividends or director’s loan repayments;
- bookkeeping being completed too late to show the accumulating liability; and
- having no system for reserving VAT during the quarter.
VAT is based on taxable sales rather than profits. A restaurant can therefore build up a substantial VAT bill while making little or no net profit after food, drink, wages, rent and other overheads.
Where margins are part of the problem, our guide to what your restaurant’s gross profit margin should be explains why small changes in gross profit can have a significant effect on the amount of cash left in the business.
The key question is whether the business generated enough cash but used it elsewhere, or whether the underlying trading model did not generate enough cash in the first place.
The answer will determine whether the solution is better budgeting, tighter cost control, price changes, refinancing or more fundamental restructuring.
How Can You Prevent the Next VAT Cash Crunch?
The most effective control is to estimate the VAT liability throughout the quarter rather than waiting until the return deadline.
For many hospitality businesses, that means:
- keeping the bookkeeping up to date at least monthly;
- reconciling EPOS, card processors and delivery platforms regularly;
- estimating the VAT liability throughout the period;
- transferring an appropriate amount into a separate VAT account or bank pot;
- including VAT, PAYE and other taxes in a rolling cash-flow forecast;
- reviewing margins, wage costs and debt repayments against budget; and
- checking the effect on upcoming tax payments before committing to new equipment, refurbishment work or finance.
The amount transferred into a VAT reserve should be based on the likely net VAT liability rather than blindly putting aside 20% of takings.
The appropriate amount will depend on the mixture of sales, the VAT rates that apply and the input VAT the business can recover on its costs.
When Is the Problem More Serious?
One missed VAT payment can be a temporary cash-flow problem.
Repeated VAT arrears, new tax debts arising during an existing Time to Pay arrangement or borrowing to repay previous borrowing may indicate that the business is not generating enough cash to meet its obligations.
Other warning signs include being unable to pay wages, rent or key suppliers, creditor balances increasing each month or forecasts showing that no realistic repayment arrangement can be maintained.
If a company cannot pay its debts as they fall due, its directors should take professional advice promptly. Getting advice early does not automatically mean closing the business. It creates more time to assess whether the position can be resolved through cost reductions, refinancing, restructuring or another recovery plan.
The Immediate Priorities
If the VAT deadline is approaching and the money is not available:
- Check that the VAT return and liability are correct.
- Submit the return on time.
- Pay as much as the business can reasonably afford.
- Prepare a realistic short-term cash-flow forecast.
- Contact HMRC early about a Time to Pay arrangement.
- Make sure any payment is allocated to the intended VAT liability.
- Identify and address the reason the cash was not available.
The earlier the business deals with the problem, the more options it is likely to have and the less it is likely to lose to interest, penalties and expensive short-term borrowing.
Please bear in mind, this article provides general information only. The appropriate action will depend on the business’s individual tax, financial and legal position.
Stay in the loop with The Hospitality Accountants
Get practical tips and updates on the numbers that matter to your hospitality business, from gross profit and labour costs to budgeting and cash flow.
Subscribe to our monthly newsletter using the form at the bottom of this page.