When is a lower margin worth it?
When reviewing a menu or drinks report, it is tempting to rank everything by gross profit (GP) percentage. But a lower margin item can put more pounds into the business each time it sells. Another product might earn less per sale but generate a worthwhile total through volume.
Look at GP percentage, GP pounds per sale and realistic sales volume together. Then consider the cost of delivering those sales.
What is the difference between GP margin and GP per sale?
- GP per item: selling price minus the ingredient or purchase cost.
- GP margin: that GP figure divided by the selling price, multiplied by 100.
The examples below are illustrative. Prices and costs exclude VAT where applicable, except for the stated £9 customer-facing pint price. Labour is considered separately; if your accounts include it within cost of sales, avoid deducting it twice.
Example: a lobster roll versus a simpler dish
| Item | Selling price | Product cost | GP per sale | GP margin |
| Lobster roll | £25.00 | £12.50 | £12.50 | 50% |
| Simpler dish | £12.00 | £3.00 | £9.00 | 75% |
- The simpler dish retains a higher percentage of its selling price.
- The lobster roll generates £3.50 more GP per sale, despite its lower margin.
The percentage tells you how much of each pound of sales remains after product cost. The pound figure tells you how much each sale leaves to cover the rest of the business’s costs.
Why do we track GP margin in management accounts?
At The Hospitality Accountants, GP margin helps us monitor food, drinks and overall trading performance across a reporting period. GP per sale helps us assess individual products. Both measures are useful, but they answer different questions.
From a management accounts perspective, GP margin helps us:
- Compare busy and quiet months. GP pounds can rise simply because turnover increased. The percentage shows whether we retained more or less of each pound sold, allowing for changes in sales mix.
- Set cost targets that move with sales. A 70% GP target allows 30% of revenue for cost of sales. We can judge costs against actual turnover, rather than treating a bigger food bill in a busy month as an automatic overspend.
- Spot changes that need investigation. A falling margin prompts checks on buying prices, menu prices, discounts, portions, waste and stock records. It may also reflect a deliberate change in the offer; the percentage flags a question rather than proving the cause.
- Build budgets and forecasts. Expected sales multiplied by an appropriate GP percentage gives expected GP pounds. Separate food and drink targets help account for the planned sales mix.
- Compare sites and departments. Percentages make different turnover levels easier to compare, provided the offers, sales mix and cost classifications are sufficiently similar.
For help choosing a suitable target for your venue, read our guide to what your restaurant’s gross profit margin should be.
Example: GP pounds rise while the margin falls
- Month one: £20,000 sales × 70% GP = £14,000 gross profit.
- Month two: £30,000 sales × 65% GP = £19,500 gross profit.
GP has increased by £5,500. But if 70% remained an appropriate target for month two’s sales mix, expected GP would be £21,000: £1,500 more than the actual result. Looking only at GP pounds could hide that gap; looking only at the percentage could overlook a commercially worthwhile change in the offer.
Use actual cost of sales with opening and closing stock adjustments, rather than treating every purchase as stock consumed that month. Calculate the overall margin as total GP ÷ total sales × 100, rather than simply averaging individual product margins.
How can a lower margin deliver the same GP?
There are two different routes: earn more pounds from each sale, or make enough additional sales to compensate for a smaller return.
Route one: fewer customers, more GP per customer
Suppose each customer buys one dish, with no other purchases:
| Service | Lower spend, higher margin | Higher spend, lower margin |
| Customers | 20 | 10 |
| Spend per customer | £15 | £40 |
| Product cost per customer | £3 | £16 |
| GP per customer | £12 | £24 |
| GP margin | 80% | 60% |
| Total GP | £240 | £240 |
Both services generate £240 GP. The lower margin offer needs half as many customers because each generates twice as many GP pounds.
Now include the additional paid labour needed to prepare and serve those meals:
- 20 customers: £3 labour each = £60, leaving £180 from the £240 GP.
- 10 customers: £4 labour each = £40, leaving £200 from the £240 GP.
The second service costs more in labour per customer but less overall. If its dishes are quicker to prepare, the advantage could grow. However:
- Fewer customers only save wages if paid hours or shifts actually change. The same salaried team working the same hours will not automatically cost less.
- Extra staffing can reverse the result. An additional £50 specialist shift would reduce the second service’s £200 to £150.
These amounts are before existing staff costs, rent and other overheads. They are not net profit.
Route two: more sales to offset lower GP per item
Consider two £4 drinks:
- Local canned beer: £2.80 purchase cost → £1.20 GP per sale, or 30%.
- Alternative drink: £1.60 purchase cost → £2.40 GP per sale, or 60%.
You need 200 cans or 100 alternative drinks to generate £240 GP. The volume approach only works if those extra sales are achievable and their additional costs do not absorb the benefit.
Selling more increases total GP pounds; it does not raise the product’s GP percentage. Check whether the new sales are additional or replace purchases customers would have made anyway.
Will enough customers buy the higher priced products?
Some products generate more GP pounds because they cost more to buy and command a higher selling price. Their appeal needs to support the sales volume in your forecast.
Example: a £9 premium pint
Assume a beer with a £9 customer-facing price generates £3 GP per pint, calculated from properly VAT-adjusted revenue and purchase cost. An alternative generates £2.50 GP per pint.
- To reach £300 GP, you need 100 premium pints or 120 alternatives.
- If demand supports only 40 premium pints, they generate £120 GP.
- If you can sell 100 alternatives, they generate £250 GP.
The premium beer needs fewer sales on paper, but the alternative may earn more in practice. These are hypothetical figures before labour and other operating costs.
A premium offer can work through the right location, a strong reason to travel, or both. Local customers may be willing and able to spend at that level. Equally, a well-known chef, distinctive product or exceptional experience can make a venue a destination. Its reputation can draw people well beyond its immediate area.
Before relying on premium products, ask:
- Who will buy at the actual menu price? Local customers, visitors, people travelling specifically to you—or a combination?
- How often will they buy? A one-off special occasion or tasting is different from regular repeat trade.
- What evidence supports the forecast? Use existing bookings, repeat purchases, trading history or a limited trial.
A range of price points may suit some venues; a focused premium offer may suit others. The key is enough demand at your intended prices, consistently enough to support the business.
When does a lower margin make commercial sense?
A lower margin can be worthwhile when it generates strong GP per sale, achieves sufficient volume, uses spare capacity or encourages profitable purchases elsewhere in the offer. Test the full effect on the business:
- Labour and capacity: What preparation, service hours or extra shifts will the sales require? Can you deliver them at peak times?
- Stock, waste and cash: How much cash is tied up, how quickly will stock sell, and what happens if it does not? Expensive products increase the cash committed per unit.
- Other costs: Include packaging, card fees, delivery commissions and any extra cleaning, maintenance or equipment required.
- The rest of the menu: Will customers spend more overall, or switch away from products that previously generated more profit?
For this assessment, introduce contribution per sale: selling price less all relevant variable costs. Compare total contribution with any additional fixed or step-up costs, such as another shift or new equipment. This takes the decision beyond product GP to the costs of delivering the plan.
For a deeper explanation of how sales volume, variable costs and fixed costs interact, see ACCA’s guide to cost-volume-profit analysis.
Bring the numbers together in your forecast
Forecast each product or sensible product group using:
Expected customers × expected items per customer × GP per item = expected GP pounds.
Then:
- Add the groups together and calculate the blended GP margin from total GP and sales.
- Check demand and capacity, including covers, average spend and table turns where relevant.
- Model the staffing, stock and other costs needed to deliver the sales.
- Test a slower sales case, so the plan does not depend entirely on the best outcome.
Our hospitality budget planning guide explores how to build these assumptions into a wider budget.
The useful question is: “How many customers will buy, how many GP pounds will each sale generate, and what will it cost us to serve them?” Review that alongside GP margin, labour, operating profit and cash flow to decide whether the plan leaves the business better off.
Stay in the loop with The Hospitality Accountants
Get practical tips and updates on the numbers that matter to your hospitality business, from gross profit and labour costs to budgeting and cash flow.
Subscribe to our monthly newsletter using the form at the bottom of this page.