Why Am I Paying Tax? I’m a Student!
Here at The Hospitality Accountants, we understand that employers of cafe’s, restaurants, bars and hotels often face the same question from their student employees: “Why am I paying tax? I’m a student!” This can be a bit tricky to answer, but don’t worry—we’ve got you covered. Let’s break it down in a way that you can easily explain to your team.
The Basics of Tax for Students
Firstly, it’s essential to understand that everyone, including students, are subject to tax if they earn above a certain amount. Taxes fund public services, from the NHS to education, and everyone contributes their share.

When Do Students Pay Tax?
Even though they are students, they might still need to pay tax depending on their earnings. Here’s what to explain to them:
- Personal Allowance: For the tax year 2024-25, the personal allowance—the amount someone can earn before they start paying income tax—is £12,570. If their total earnings for the year are below this threshold, they won’t pay income tax.
- Employment Income: If they work part-time during term or full-time during holidays and their total annual earnings exceed the personal allowance, they’ll be taxed on the excess amount.
- National Insurance Contributions (NICs): Once they earn more than £242 a week (in the 2024-25 tax year), they’ll start paying NICs. This is also something they need to be aware of.
Common Reasons for Tax Deductions
Sometimes, even if a student doesn’t earn above the personal allowance, they might still see tax being deducted. Here’s why:
- Emergency Tax Codes: If they start a new job, they might be placed on an emergency tax code until HMRC provides the correct one. This temporary code can result in higher tax deductions.
- Multiple Jobs: If they have more than one job, the personal allowance usually applies to only one job, with other income taxed at the basic rate.
- Incorrect Tax Code: Errors can occur, leading to an incorrect tax code being applied. It’s always good to check their tax code on their payslip. If they don’t think the tax code is correct, they need to contact HMRC to discuss this further. As payroll providers we can only apply the tax code that HMRC tell us to use.
- High level of earnings early on in the Tax Year:The tax code system calculates tax on income and the distribution of the Tax-Free Personal Allowance using the cumulative calculation method. Consequently, if employees earn a high income early in the tax year (often due to seasonality), the system assumes this level of earnings will continue throughout the year. When students return to school, college, or university and their earnings decrease, they are likely to receive tax refunds for overpaid tax.
Reclaiming Overpaid Tax
Tax amounts are usually ironed out within the tax year through the use of tax codes. However, if it’s gone past the tax year end and one of your team members has paid too much tax, there are ways to reclaim the overpaid amount:
- P800 or Simple Assessment: HMRC will send a P800 tax calculation or a Simple Assessment if they’ve overpaid. They should follow the instructions to claim their refund.
- Contact HMRC: If your studends don’t receive a P800. We suggest that they contact HMRC to clarify the reasons they believe they might have paid the incorrect amount of tax, and confirm that HMRC have the correct address on record.
- Self-Assessment: If your students are registered for self-assessment, once they complete and submit their Tax Return, the overpaid tax will be refunded accordingly.
Note: Student Loans: Ensure they are aware of their student loan repayments, as overpayments can also occur here.
Practical Tips for Employers
Here are some practical tips you can share with your student employees:
- Check Payslips: Encourage them to regularly check their payslips for the correct tax code and deductions.
- Keep Records: Advise them to keep all their payslips, P60s, and P45s. These are essential for tax purposes and claiming refunds.
- HMRC Resources: Point them towards HMRC’s online tools and calculators. These resources can help them understand their tax situation better.
Final Thoughts
Paying tax is a part of working life, even for students. By understanding the basics and keeping an eye on their earnings and tax codes, they can ensure they’re not paying more than they should. As employers, it’s beneficial to provide them with this knowledge and support.
If you or your employees have more questions, feel free to reach out to us at The Hospitality Accountants. We’re here to help make the financial aspects of your business run smoothly, so you can focus on what you do best—providing excellent hospitality!